How Smart CISOs Pick the Right Vendors Thumbnail

Here's a draft of your blog in the voice of Alex Hormozi:

How Smart CISOs Choose the Right Vendor: A Strategic Approach

Most people are making vendor selection WAY harder than it needs to be. The reality? You don’t just choose a vendor—you choose a partner that either accelerates your security strategy or blows it up from the inside.

And yet, so many CISOs screw this up. They pick vendors based on who’s loudest in the market, who has the shiniest product, or who makes the best sales pitch. Then six months later, they’re dealing with poor performance, bad service, and security gaps they should’ve caught before signing on the dotted line.

So, let’s break this down properly. How do the smartest CISOs pick vendors that don’t just work—but actually make their job easier?

Defining the Right Selection Criteria

Understanding Business Needs and Compliance Requirements

Here’s where most people trip up: they think vendor selection is about checking off boxes. "Do they have SOC 2? Do they have ISO 27001?" Yeah, cool. But compliance doesn’t mean competence.

You need to step back and ask, What problem are we solving? A vendor might have all the certifications in the world, but if they can’t solve your security problems, who cares?

Compliance is important, but it’s baseline. The real question is: Do they fit your specific business needs? If they don’t, move on.

Evaluating Vendor Reputation and Stability

Look, I love startups. They move fast, innovate, and challenge the big guys. But there are certain areas where a shaky vendor can take down your entire security stack.

Some vendors just don’t have the resources to support a large-scale deployment. And if their revenue isn’t stable? You could be left with a half-baked product, or worse—no product at all.

The best CISOs evaluate vendors like investors evaluate companies:

  1. Longevity – Have they been around long enough to prove they can scale?
  2. Reputation – Are other major players using them, or is it just hype?
  3. Financials – Are they making real money, or are they surviving on VC fumes?

If a vendor doesn’t pass these tests, they’re a risk—not an asset.

The Role of Security Questionnaires—Necessary but Flawed?

Security questionnaires are a joke. A necessary joke, but a joke nonetheless.

We’ve overcomplicated this entire process to the point where it’s slowing down real security work. I know CISOs who are dealing with thousands of questionnaires a year. And what’s the result? Just another checkbox exercise.

The industry needs to standardize this stuff—because right now, we’re wasting time on redundant forms that don’t actually make our environments safer. Until that happens, the best move? Simplify internally. Cut the fluff. Focus on what really matters in vendor risk assessments.

Building Strong Vendor Relationships

Beyond the Contract—The Importance of Executive-Level Engagement

This is a huge unlock that most CISOs ignore: Build a relationship with vendor leadership BEFORE you need it.

Why? Because when things go south—and they will—you don’t want to be stuck in a support ticket loop. You need a direct line to the CTO or CEO, so when you say, “Fix this,” it gets fixed.

I’ve seen firsthand how powerful this is. One CISO I know had a vendor issue that was impacting business operations. Instead of dealing with customer support, he called the CTO directly. Within weeks, they reallocated resources to fix the problem.

That’s what you want. That’s what actually protects your business.

Proof of Concept: Can the Vendor Deliver at Scale?

Any vendor can say they solve your problem. But can they prove it? At scale?

The best CISOs never just take a vendor’s word for it. They run proof-of-concept tests at a meaningful scale—because what works in a small demo environment might crash and burn when deployed across the entire company.

And here’s a pro tip: Make vendors work for it. If they’re serious about your business, they’ll want to prove their solution actually works for you.

Managing Risks Through Contracts and Escalation Paths

Most contracts are written for the vendor, not for you.

If you’re not negotiating strong SLAs and escalation paths upfront, you’re setting yourself up for headaches. What happens when the tool fails? What’s their response time? How do they prove they’re fixing the issue?

The best CISOs make sure contracts have clear accountability. No vague promises—just hard commitments.

Long-Term Vendor Management: Ensuring Continuous Value

Quarterly Business Reviews: Measuring Vendor Performance

Here’s the deal: Your vendors should be earning their keep every quarter. If you’re not holding regular QBRs (Quarterly Business Reviews), you have no idea if they’re actually delivering.

QBRs should answer three simple questions:

  1. Are they solving the problem we hired them for?
  2. Have they introduced any new risks or inefficiencies?
  3. What’s next—how do they continue to add value?

If a vendor can’t answer those clearly, they might not be the right partner long term.

Handling Incidents: Vendor Response and Recovery

When things break (because they will), what matters is how fast your vendor moves to fix it.

This is why vendor selection isn’t just about features—it’s about operational excellence. The best vendors have clear, documented response plans. If they don’t, you’re rolling the dice with your security.

Data Security and the Shared Responsibility Model

You can’t outsource security. Period.

Even if you’re using a vendor, you’re still responsible for your company’s risk. The best CISOs think about security like an ecosystem—they know exactly what data they’re sharing, how it’s being used, and what the potential exposure points are.

If you’re not taking ownership of that, you’re just waiting for a breach to happen.

The Future of Vendor Security Assessments: Can We Standardize?

If the security industry was smart, we’d stop reinventing the wheel with every vendor questionnaire.

Imagine if 80% of vendor security questions were pre-standardized, and companies only had to customize the last 20% for their specific risk tolerance. It would cut down on the wasted time and make the whole process smoother.

Will this happen anytime soon? Probably not. But the best CISOs are already moving in this direction—creating internal frameworks to speed up vendor assessments without compromising security.

Conclusion

Vendor selection isn’t just about checking boxes—it’s about picking partners that help you secure your business without adding unnecessary friction.

The best CISOs follow a simple process:

  1. Get clear on business needs first—Compliance is the starting point, not the whole game.
  2. Vet vendors like investors—Look at longevity, reputation, and financial stability.
  3. Build real relationships—A direct line to vendor leadership can save you months of headaches.
  4. Test at scale before committing—A small proof-of-concept means nothing if the solution doesn’t scale.
  5. Hold vendors accountable—Through strong contracts, QBRs, and defined escalation paths.

Security isn’t about avoiding problems—it’s about handling them better than the competition. The right vendor isn’t just a supplier; they’re a force multiplier for your security strategy.

So, choose wisely. Your business depends on it.